Try the Pasta!.
I love Catalano's pizza. Their sauce and incredibly fresh toppings are unmatched. In addition to great pizza, I would suggest you try their Spaghetti dinner. Love the rich homemade sauce and meatballs. If you don't have time to make a really good spaghetti sauce, this will do nicely. Something to note, they don't have much seating area and it is quite plain inside. Don't let that fool you. Just plan on having them deliver if you live in the area or pick up your order and take it home. It is worth the trouble.